Joe's Brooklyn Pizza Henrietta

Emily Gisleson 4 months ago

I stumbled into Joe's Brooklyn Pizza through Too Good to Go and walked away a convert. Last night I got to sample four slices — Buffalo Chicken, Grandma's, Old Fashioned, and Margherita — and every single one delivered. The crust is the real story here. That Brooklyn-style thin crisp is no joke: sturdy enough to hold its toppings, a little char, and still foldable. It snaps when you bite into it. You can tell this isn't an accident — someone here actually cares about getting it right. The Margherita and Old Fashioned were exactly what you want from a classic slice. Grandma's had that satisfying density without being heavy. And the Buffalo Chicken? I'll be honest — I'm not a Buffalo Chicken pizza person. Except apparently I am now, because that slice was genuinely good. If you're in the area and you want pizza made with actual craft and intention, Joe's is worth your time (and your appetite).

Josh Hauck 6 months ago

I recently tried Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza in Henrietta, and it was fantastic. I ordered one of their stuffed pizzas, and it honestly blew me away. The crust was perfectly baked—crispy on the outside but still soft inside—and the amount of cheese and toppings packed into the pizza was incredible. Every bite was rich, flavorful, and clearly made with care. You can really tell they put effort into doing pizza the right way. If you’re anywhere near Henrietta and craving a serious, hearty slice, I definitely recommend giving Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza a try. I’ll absolutely be going back!

OLive Villalon 6 months ago

This pizza place is a must try! If you love thin crust pizza with a very nice Italian dough and a very generous serving then this is the place for you! Highly recommended!

JB 6 months ago

Really, Joe's, could you spare the pepperoni and cheese? We ordered a large, thin crust pizza with cheese and pepperoni on half the pizza. And, we're seriously disappointed. There's barely any pepperoni on it. And, not only is there not much cheese, but they don't even put the cheese to the edge of the crust. (I'm not talking cheese right on the edge, but up to the edge of the crust, like a regular pizza normally is.) $26 for a pizza that isn't even well-covered with the ingredients that you're paying for? And, if you're going to charge me full price for an ingredient that is only on half the pizza, then give me the full amount of that ingredient on half the pizza. No thanks. We really like Joe's Brooklyn-style thin crust, but won't be ordering from them again. There are at least 30 pizza places just around this area. With so much competition, you should do better, Joe's.

Chris Fatality a year ago

This location is not the greatest. I went there yesterday ordered two pizzas roughly around 130$. Which seem excessive however I do food reviews and I don't mind giving places business. However this place the customer service was a turn off. The girl at the counter acted like we were nothing her by simply placing a order. (Which is odd considering that's what you do with a cashier). The pizza had zero flavor the pulled pork BBQ just tasted like it had a overwhelming amount of spice to be BBQ sauce. The "mac&Cheese pizza just tasted like bland boiled noodles and maybe a hint of cheese. It was very one note and flat. Just to make sure i was not the only one I did other reviews with people and alot had the similar take on it. We had to clean our own table which is weird considering it was only one of ther person in the restaurant so you would assume "if you had time to lean you had time to clean" method would happen but it's been awhile since I've cooking in a kitchen so what do I know. I plan to try other locations trying different pizza's and letting you guys know. But this location about the bland food and terrible customer service is correct. Hopefully they do better but I will